Use caseCommercial property
The broker sends nine attachments and wants a quote in ten days. Two years of loss runs are missing, and nobody notices until the due date.
The pack is checked against your guidelines the hour it arrivesThe broker gets a precise request the next dayThe underwriter prices, and the manager approves above the limit
The activity is within appetite and the values are under $50M. But the loss runs cover 3 years of 5, and the survey dates from March 2023.
source · 9 documents in the submissionA piece is missing · the AI names it, with its source
Forty to sixty property submissions reach a commercial lines team every week. Each one is an email with seven to fifteen attachments: an application, a schedule of values, loss runs, a survey report, certificates. Ridgeline Castings sent nine, and two years of loss runs were not among them. The underwriter learns that the day she finally opens the pack.
Within the hour it lands, the pack is read. The AI types each attachment, pulls the values and the losses into the submission, and checks the whole pack against your underwriting guidelines. The underwriter starts from the gaps and the figures, and keeps the price and the terms.
An underwriter knows all four of these screens. Their order decides the outcome: the pack is read the hour it arrives, the broker is asked for the missing pieces while there is still time, and the quote is built on a complete file. The three acts below stay with Ridgeline Castings until the quote leaves, two days early.
Megan Hayes has not opened the email yet. The pack is already filed, read and held against the guidelines.
On Monday at 11:20, Mark Hollis of Hollis Risk Partners sends a renewal for Ridgeline Castings, a metal parts maker with two sites near Cleveland, Ohio. The email reaches the brokers' mailbox with nine attachments. Capture creates a submission case, links it to the broker and gives each attachment its type.
The AI reads the schedule of values and the application, and writes the figures into the submission: two sites, the foundry at Parma for $24.6M and the machining plant at Solon for $13.8M, plus the construction, the sprinklers and the business interruption sum.
One value is missing. The application says insulated metal panels on site 1 and never states their core, which matters on a site with hot work.
Your guidelines for metalworking risks ask for five years of loss runs, a survey less than three years old and the panel core on hot work sites. The underwriting manager wrote them in plain language. An AI agent runs the pack against them and writes a status and its reasoning onto the submission.
Here the status is Attention required: the loss runs start in 2023, the survey dates from March 2023, and the panel core is not stated.
Twelve submissions on Megan's list this week. Which ones first, and what does each broker still owe her?
Megan's queue shows each submission with its verdict, its values and the date the broker needs an answer. Ridgeline Castings is the largest. She asks the assistant whether she can quote it within her authority.
Megan asks the assistant for a request to Mark. The draft lists the 2021 and 2022 loss runs and the panel core material, with the client name and the quote date already in it. She adds an offer to visit the site with the risk engineer, and sends it. The step carries a three-day timer.
While the broker gathers the documents, Megan opens the 2023 survey in the viewer, next to the submission. She asks which recommendations are still open, and the answer points to the pages. Julie Bennett, the risk engineer, opens the same page and leaves a note on R2.
The broker's reply arrives on Thursday. The price is Megan's to set, inside the limits her manager wrote. Three steps take it to the broker.
The 2021 and 2022 loss runs and the broker's answer on the panels come in by email and are filed on the same submission. The AI extracts each loss with its year, cause and amount, the check runs again, and the status moves to Complete.
Megan enters a rate of $0.118 per $100 of insured values, a $25,000 deductible, and a $100,000 deductible for fire in the extraction system until R2 is closed. Three conditions come with the quote, two of them before inception, and each becomes a task on the submission. Because the values exceed $30M, the approval path sends the quote to David Mercer, who approves the same afternoon.
The quote document comes from your rating tool through the API and is filed on the submission. Megan asks the assistant for the cover letter. The draft explains the premium, the two deductibles and the conditions, with their reason in the survey. She softens one sentence and sends it on Nov 18, two days early.
The AI never sets a premium. It reads the pack against your guidelines and names its state, and that state decides whether Megan prices, asks or declines.
Activity, values, loss history, survey, protection. One line on the submission records that each guideline held.
Next: the underwriter reads the risk and prices it.Loss runs too short, a survey too old, a value not stated. The analysis says which, with its source.
Next: the broker gets a precise request; the check runs again when the reply arrives.The AI lists what fits first, then names the guideline the risk falls outside.
Next: a reasoned decline, written and signed by the underwriter.It sets no rate, accepts no risk and declines no broker. Across the nine steps on this page, the price and the terms are the underwriter's, and the approval above her authority is her manager's.
The AI reads, extracts, checks and drafts. The control is in how the guidelines and the approval path are written, so it holds in the busiest renewal season.
Counted on Ridgeline Castings, one renewal over ten days. A pack with fifteen attachments or a stricter guideline will count differently.
Where these numbers come from. They are counted on the scenario described on this page, with example data. They are not a customer result.
The underwriter, her manager and the CIO each need a reason before a property team works this way.
Most of the week goes into opening attachments, and the risk gets what time is left.
Quotes reach you for approval with no sign of how the guidelines were applied.
The brokers' mailbox, the rating tool and the policy system have never been introduced.
With one guideline set. Take the checklist your underwriters run by hand on every property pack, and move it to the door. A season of renewals is enough to judge it.
Your brokers' mailbox, your rating tool and your policy system stay where they are. The check sits between them.
Next step
Bring an anonymized submission pack and your underwriting guidelines. Watch the check run on your own documents, then decide on the price yourself.